Dear fellow Matlab users, Recently I have made good use of Matlab's built-in functions for making linear mixed effects. Currently I am trying to model time-series data (neuronal activity) from c...6 Linear mixed-effects models with one random factor. 6.1 Learning objectives; 6.2 When, and why, would you want to replace conventional analyses with linear mixed-effects modeling? 6.3 Example: Independent-samples \(t\)-test on multi-level data. 6.3.1 When is a random-intercepts model appropriate? Nov 1, 2019 · Therefore, even greater sampling rates will be required when autocorrelation is present to meet the levels prescribed by analyses of the power and precision when estimating individual variation using mixed effect models (e.g., Wolak et al. 2012; Dingemanse and Dochtermann 2013) Sep 22, 2015 · $\begingroup$ it's more a please check that I have taken care of the random effects, autocorrelation, and a variance that increases with the mean properly. $\endgroup$ – M.T.West Sep 22, 2015 at 12:15 Segmented linear regression models are often fitted to ITS data using a range of estimation methods [8,9,10,11]. Commonly ordinary least squares (OLS) is used to estimate the model parameters ; however, the method does not account for autocorrelation. Other statistical methods are available that attempt to account for autocorrelation in ...May 5, 2022 · The PBmodcomp function can only be used to compare models of the same type and thus could not be used to test an LME model (Model IV) versus a linear model (Model V), an autocorrelation model (Model VIII) versus a linear model (Model V), or a mixed effects autocorrelation model (Models VI-VII) versus an autocorrelation model (Model VIII). lmer (lme4) glmmTMB (glmmTMB) We will start by fitting the linear mixed effects model. data.hier.lme <- lme(y ~ x, random = ~1 | block, data.hier, method = "REML") The hierarchical random effects structure is defined by the random= parameter. In this case, random=~1|block indicates that blocks are random effects and that the intercept should be ...the mixed-effect model with a first-order autocorrelation structure. The model was estimated using the R package nlme and the lme function (Pinheiro et al., 2020 ).Autocorrelation in linear mixed models (lme) Ask Question Asked 3 years, 1 month ago Modified 3 years, 1 month ago Viewed 4k times 4 To study the diving behaviour of whales, I have a dataframe where each row corresponds to a dive (id) carried out by a tagged individual (whale).However, in the nlme R code, both methods inhabit the ‘correlation = CorStruc’ code which can only be used once in a model. Therefore, it appears that either only spatial autocorrelation or only temporal autocorrelation can be addressed, but not both (see example code below).Linear mixed model fit by maximum likelihood [’lmerMod’] AIC BIC logLik deviance df.resid 22.5 25.5 -8.3 16.5 17 Random effects: Groups Name Variance Std.Dev. operator (Intercept) 0.04575 0.2139 *** Operator var Residual 0.10625 0.3260 estimate is smaller. Number of obs: 20, groups: operator, 4 Results in smaller SE for the overall Fixed ... I have a dataset of 12 days of diary data. I am trying to use lme to model the effect of sleep quality on stress, with random intercept effects of participant and random slope effect of sleep quality. I am not particularly interested in asking whether there was change over time from diaryday 1 to 12, just in accounting for the time variable. The PBmodcomp function can only be used to compare models of the same type and thus could not be used to test an LME model (Model IV) versus a linear model (Model V), an autocorrelation model (Model VIII) versus a linear model (Model V), or a mixed effects autocorrelation model (Models VI-VII) versus an autocorrelation model (Model VIII).Feb 28, 2020 · There is spatial autocorrelation in the data which has been identified using a variogram and Moran's I. The problem is I tried to run a lme model, with a random effect of the State that district is within: mod.cor<-lme(FLkm ~ Monsoon.Precip + Monsoon.Temp,correlation=corGaus(form=~x+y,nugget=TRUE), data=NE1, random = ~1|State) Apr 15, 2021 · Yes. How can glmmTMB tell how far apart moments in time are if the time sequence must be provided as a factor? The assumption is that successive levels of the factor are one time step apart (the ar1 () covariance structure does not allow for unevenly spaced time steps: for that you need the ou () covariance structure, for which you need to use ... Phi = 0.914; > - we have a significant treatment effect; > - and when I calculate effective degrees of freedom (after Zuur et al "Mixed Effects Models and Extensions in Ecology with R" pg.113) I get 13.1; hence we aren't getting much extra information from each time-series given the level of autocorrelation, but at least we have dealt with data ...Mixed-effects models allow multiple levels of variability; AKA hierarchical models, multilevel models, multistratum models; Good references on mixed-effects models: Bolker [1–3] Gelman & Hill [4] Pinheiro & Bates [5].c (Claudia Czado, TU Munich) – 11 – Likelihood Inference for LMM: 1) Estimation of β and γ for known G and R Estimation of β: Using (5), we have as MLE or weighted LSE of βof freedom obtained by the same method used in the most recently fit mixed model. If option dfmethod() is not specified in the previous mixed command, option small is not allowed. For certain methods, the degrees of freedom for some linear combinations may not be available. See Small-sample inference for fixed effects in[ME] mixed for more ... Phi = 0.914; > - we have a significant treatment effect; > - and when I calculate effective degrees of freedom (after Zuur et al "Mixed Effects Models and Extensions in Ecology with R" pg.113) I get 13.1; hence we aren't getting much extra information from each time-series given the level of autocorrelation, but at least we have dealt with data ...To use such data for predicting feelings, beliefs, and behavior, recent methodological work suggested combinations of the longitudinal mixed-effect model with Lasso regression or with regressi … A Lasso and a Regression Tree Mixed-Effect Model with Random Effects for the Level, the Residual Variance, and the Autocorrelation Yes. How can glmmTMB tell how far apart moments in time are if the time sequence must be provided as a factor? The assumption is that successive levels of the factor are one time step apart (the ar1 () covariance structure does not allow for unevenly spaced time steps: for that you need the ou () covariance structure, for which you need to use ...Spatial and temporal autocorrelation can be problematic because they violate the assumption that the residuals in regression are independent, which causes estimated standard errors of parameters to be biased and causes parametric statistics no longer follow their expected distributions (i.e. p-values are too low).Aug 8, 2018 · 3. MIXED EFFECTS MODELS 3.1 Overview of mixed effects models When a regression contains both random and fixed effects, it is said to be a mixed effects model, or simply, a mixed model. Fixed effects are those with which most researchers are familiar. Any covariate that is assumed to have the same effect for all responses throughout the Mar 29, 2021 · Ultimately I'd like to include spatial autocorrelation with corSpatial(form = ~ lat + long) in the GAMM model, or s(lat,long) in the GAM model, but even in basic form I can't get the model to run. If it helps understand the structure of the data, I've added dummy code below (with 200,000 rows): I have a dataset of 12 days of diary data. I am trying to use lme to model the effect of sleep quality on stress, with random intercept effects of participant and random slope effect of sleep quality. I am not particularly interested in asking whether there was change over time from diaryday 1 to 12, just in accounting for the time variable.May 22, 2018 · 10.8k 7 39 67. 1. All LMMs correspond to a multivariate normal model (while the converse is not true) with a structured variance covariance matrix, so "all" you have to do is to work out the marginal variance covariance matrix for the nested random-effect model and fit that - whether gls is then able to parameterize that model is then the next ... Jan 7, 2016 · Linear mixed-effect model without repeated measurements. The OLS model indicated that additional modeling components are necessary to account for individual-level clustering and residual autocorrelation. Linear mixed-effect models allow for non-independence and clustering by describing both between and within individual differences. Aug 9, 2023 · Arguments. the value of the lag 1 autocorrelation, which must be between -1 and 1. Defaults to 0 (no autocorrelation). a one sided formula of the form ~ t, or ~ t | g, specifying a time covariate t and, optionally, a grouping factor g. A covariate for this correlation structure must be integer valued. When a grouping factor is present in form ... Models all contained the same fixed effects, were compared using AIC, and were fitted by REML (to allow comparison of different correlation structures by AIC). I'm using the R package nlme and the gls function. Question 1. The GLS models' residuals still display almost identical cyclical patterns when plotted against time.3. MIXED EFFECTS MODELS 3.1 Overview of mixed effects models When a regression contains both random and fixed effects, it is said to be a mixed effects model, or simply, a mixed model. Fixed effects are those with which most researchers are familiar. Any covariate that is assumed to have the same effect for all responses throughout the7. I want to specify different random effects in a model using nlme::lme (data at the bottom). The random effects are: 1) intercept and position varies over subject; 2) intercept varies over comparison. This is straightforward using lme4::lmer: lmer (rating ~ 1 + position + (1 + position | subject) + (1 | comparison), data=d) > ...Nov 1, 2019 · Therefore, even greater sampling rates will be required when autocorrelation is present to meet the levels prescribed by analyses of the power and precision when estimating individual variation using mixed effect models (e.g., Wolak et al. 2012; Dingemanse and Dochtermann 2013) The first model was a longitudinal mixed-effect model with a first-order autocorrelation structure, and the second model was the E-MELS. Both were implemented as described above. The third model was a longitudinal mixed-effect model with a Lasso penalty.The “random effects model” (also known as the mixed effects model) is used when the analysis must account for both fixed and random effects in the model. This occurs when data for a subject are independent observations following a linear model or GLM, but the regression coefficients vary from person to person. Infant growth is aEight models were estimated in which subjects nervousness values were regressed on all aforementioned predictors. The first model was a standard mixed-effects model with random effects for the intercept and the slope but no autocorrelation (Model 1 in Tables 2 and 3). The second model included such an autocorrelation (Model 2).Growth curve models (possibly Latent GCM) Mixed effects models. 이 모두는 mixed model 의 다른 종류를 말한다. 어떤 용어들은 역사가 깊고, 어떤 것들은 특수 분야에서 자주 사용되고, 어떤 것들은 특정 데이터 구조를 뜻하고, 어떤 것들은 특수한 케이스들이다. Mixed effects 혹은 mixed ...Jan 7, 2016 · Linear mixed-effect model without repeated measurements. The OLS model indicated that additional modeling components are necessary to account for individual-level clustering and residual autocorrelation. Linear mixed-effect models allow for non-independence and clustering by describing both between and within individual differences. Linear mixed-effect model without repeated measurements. The OLS model indicated that additional modeling components are necessary to account for individual-level clustering and residual autocorrelation. Linear mixed-effect models allow for non-independence and clustering by describing both between and within individual differences.Aug 14, 2021 · the mixed-effect model with a first-order autocorrelation structure. The model was estimated using the R package nlme and the lme function (Pinheiro et al., 2020 ). You should try many of them and keep the best model. In this case the spatial autocorrelation in considered as continous and could be approximated by a global function. Second, you could go with the package mgcv, and add a bivariate spline (spatial coordinates) to your model. This way, you could capture a spatial pattern and even map it.the mixed-effect model with a first-order autocorrelation structure. The model was estimated using the R package nlme and the lme function (Pinheiro et al., 2020 ).Your second model is a random-slopes model; it allows for random variation in the individual-level slopes (and in the intercept, and a correlation between slopes and intercepts) m2 <- update(m1, random = ~ minutes|ID) I'd suggest the random-slopes model is more appropriate (see e.g. Schielzeth and Forstmeier 2009). Some other considerations:Abstract. The use of linear mixed effects models (LMMs) is increasingly common in the analysis of biological data. Whilst LMMs offer a flexible approach to modelling a broad range of data types, ecological data are often complex and require complex model structures, and the fitting and interpretation of such models is not always straightforward.Spatial and temporal autocorrelation can be problematic because they violate the assumption that the residuals in regression are independent, which causes estimated standard errors of parameters to be biased and causes parametric statistics no longer follow their expected distributions (i.e. p-values are too low).Models all contained the same fixed effects, were compared using AIC, and were fitted by REML (to allow comparison of different correlation structures by AIC). I'm using the R package nlme and the gls function. Question 1. The GLS models' residuals still display almost identical cyclical patterns when plotted against time.Aug 8, 2018 · 3. MIXED EFFECTS MODELS 3.1 Overview of mixed effects models When a regression contains both random and fixed effects, it is said to be a mixed effects model, or simply, a mixed model. Fixed effects are those with which most researchers are familiar. Any covariate that is assumed to have the same effect for all responses throughout the in nlme, it is possible to specify the variance-covariance matrix for the random effects (e.g. an AR (1)); it is not possible in lme4. Now, lme4 can easily handle very huge number of random effects (hence, number of individuals in a given study) thanks to its C part and the use of sparse matrices. The nlme package has somewhat been superseded ...Therefore, even greater sampling rates will be required when autocorrelation is present to meet the levels prescribed by analyses of the power and precision when estimating individual variation using mixed effect models (e.g., Wolak et al. 2012; Dingemanse and Dochtermann 2013)7. I want to specify different random effects in a model using nlme::lme (data at the bottom). The random effects are: 1) intercept and position varies over subject; 2) intercept varies over comparison. This is straightforward using lme4::lmer: lmer (rating ~ 1 + position + (1 + position | subject) + (1 | comparison), data=d) > ...1 Answer. Mixed models are often a good choice when you have repeated measures, such as here, within whales. lme from the nlme package can fit mixed models and also handle autocorrelation based on a AR (1) process, where values of X X at t − 1 t − 1 determine the values of X X at t t.of freedom obtained by the same method used in the most recently fit mixed model. If option dfmethod() is not specified in the previous mixed command, option small is not allowed. For certain methods, the degrees of freedom for some linear combinations may not be available. See Small-sample inference for fixed effects in[ME] mixed for more ... of freedom obtained by the same method used in the most recently fit mixed model. If option dfmethod() is not specified in the previous mixed command, option small is not allowed. For certain methods, the degrees of freedom for some linear combinations may not be available. See Small-sample inference for fixed effects in[ME] mixed for more ...6 Linear mixed-effects models with one random factor. 6.1 Learning objectives; 6.2 When, and why, would you want to replace conventional analyses with linear mixed-effects modeling? 6.3 Example: Independent-samples \(t\)-test on multi-level data. 6.3.1 When is a random-intercepts model appropriate?spaMM fits mixed-effect models and allow the inclusion of spatial effect in different forms (Matern, Interpolated Markov Random Fields, CAR / AR1) but also provide interesting other features such as non-gaussian random effects or autocorrelated random coefficient (ie group-specific spatial dependency). spaMM uses a syntax close to the one used ...Jul 1, 2021 · Mixed Effects Models - Autocorrelation. Jul. 1, 2021 • 0 likes • 171 views. Download Now. Download to read offline. Education. Lecture 19 from my mixed-effects modeling course: Autocorrelation in longitudinal and time-series data. Scott Fraundorf Follow. Apr 15, 2021 · Yes. How can glmmTMB tell how far apart moments in time are if the time sequence must be provided as a factor? The assumption is that successive levels of the factor are one time step apart (the ar1 () covariance structure does not allow for unevenly spaced time steps: for that you need the ou () covariance structure, for which you need to use ... Generalized additive models were flrst proposed by Hastie and Tibshirani (1986, 1990). These models assume that the mean of the response variable depends on an additive pre-dictor through a link function. Like generalized linear models (GLMs), generalized additive models permit the response probability distribution to be any member of the ...Jul 7, 2020 · 1 Answer. Mixed models are often a good choice when you have repeated measures, such as here, within whales. lme from the nlme package can fit mixed models and also handle autocorrelation based on a AR (1) process, where values of X X at t − 1 t − 1 determine the values of X X at t t. Feb 10, 2022 · An extension of the mixed-effects growth model that considers between-person differences in the within-subject variance and the autocorrelation. Stat Med. 2022 Feb 10;41 (3):471-482. doi: 10.1002/sim.9280. $\begingroup$ it's more a please check that I have taken care of the random effects, autocorrelation, and a variance that increases with the mean properly. $\endgroup$ – M.T.West Sep 22, 2015 at 12:15Eight models were estimated in which subjects nervousness values were regressed on all aforementioned predictors. The first model was a standard mixed-effects model with random effects for the intercept and the slope but no autocorrelation (Model 1 in Tables 2 and 3). The second model included such an autocorrelation (Model 2). a random effect for the autocorrelation. After introducing the extended mixed-effect location scale (E-MELS), ... mixed-effect models that have been, for example, combined with Lasso regression (e ...Nov 1, 2019 · Therefore, even greater sampling rates will be required when autocorrelation is present to meet the levels prescribed by analyses of the power and precision when estimating individual variation using mixed effect models (e.g., Wolak et al. 2012; Dingemanse and Dochtermann 2013) Jul 1, 2021 · Mixed Effects Models - Autocorrelation. Jul. 1, 2021 • 0 likes • 171 views. Download Now. Download to read offline. Education. Lecture 19 from my mixed-effects modeling course: Autocorrelation in longitudinal and time-series data. Scott Fraundorf Follow. Recently I have made good use of Matlab's built-in functions for making linear mixed effects. Currently I am trying to model time-series data (neuronal activity) from cognitive experiments with the fitlme() function using two continuous fixed effects (linear speed and acceleration) and several, hierarchically nested categorical random factors (subject identity, experimental session and binned ...a combination of both models (ARMA). random effects that model independence among observations from the same site using GAMMs. That is, in addition to changing the basis as with the nottem example, we can also add complexity to the model by incorporating an autocorrelation structure or mixed effects using the gamm() function in the mgcv package1 Answer. Mixed models are often a good choice when you have repeated measures, such as here, within whales. lme from the nlme package can fit mixed models and also handle autocorrelation based on a AR (1) process, where values of X X at t − 1 t − 1 determine the values of X X at t t.Your second model is a random-slopes model; it allows for random variation in the individual-level slopes (and in the intercept, and a correlation between slopes and intercepts) m2 <- update(m1, random = ~ minutes|ID) I'd suggest the random-slopes model is more appropriate (see e.g. Schielzeth and Forstmeier 2009). Some other considerations: Growth curve models (possibly Latent GCM) Mixed effects models. 이 모두는 mixed model 의 다른 종류를 말한다. 어떤 용어들은 역사가 깊고, 어떤 것들은 특수 분야에서 자주 사용되고, 어떤 것들은 특정 데이터 구조를 뜻하고, 어떤 것들은 특수한 케이스들이다. Mixed effects 혹은 mixed ...We conducted a small simulation study to investigate whether an extension of the mixed-effect model that considers between-person differences in the Level 1 variance and the autocorrelation (i.e., the E-MELS) yields more precise forecasts than a standard longitudinal mixed-effect model.Jan 7, 2016 · Linear mixed-effect model without repeated measurements. The OLS model indicated that additional modeling components are necessary to account for individual-level clustering and residual autocorrelation. Linear mixed-effect models allow for non-independence and clustering by describing both between and within individual differences. How is it possible that the model fits perfectly the data while the fixed effect is far from overfitting ? Is it normal that including the temporal autocorrelation process gives such R² and almost a perfect fit ? (largely due to the random part, fixed part often explains a small part of the variance in my data). Is the model still interpretable ?Mixed Effects Models - Autocorrelation. Jul. 1, 2021 • 0 likes • 171 views. Download Now. Download to read offline. Education. Lecture 19 from my mixed-effects modeling course: Autocorrelation in longitudinal and time-series data. Scott Fraundorf Follow.A comparison to mixed models. We noted previously that there were ties between generalized additive and mixed models. Aside from the identical matrix representation noted in the technical section, one of the key ideas is that the penalty parameter for the smooth coefficients reflects the ratio of the residual variance to the variance components for the random effects (see Fahrmeier et al ...This example will use a mixed effects model to describe the repeated measures analysis, using the lme function in the nlme package. Student is treated as a random variable in the model. The autocorrelation structure is described with the correlation statement.Feb 3, 2021 · I have temporal blocks in my data frame, so I took the effect of time dependency through a random intercept in a glmer model. Now I want to test the spatial autocorrelation in the residuals but I’m not sure if the test procedure based on the residual is the same as for the fixed-effect models since now I have time dependency. 1 Answer. Mixed models are often a good choice when you have repeated measures, such as here, within whales. lme from the nlme package can fit mixed models and also handle autocorrelation based on a AR (1) process, where values of X X at t − 1 t − 1 determine the values of X X at t t.$\begingroup$ it's more a please check that I have taken care of the random effects, autocorrelation, and a variance that increases with the mean properly. $\endgroup$ – M.T.West Sep 22, 2015 at 12:15Models all contained the same fixed effects, were compared using AIC, and were fitted by REML (to allow comparison of different correlation structures by AIC). I'm using the R package nlme and the gls function. Question 1. The GLS models' residuals still display almost identical cyclical patterns when plotted against time.The code below shows how the random effects (intercepts) of mixed models without autocorrelation terms can be extracted and plotted. However, this approach does not work when modelling autocorrelation in glmmTMB. Use reproducible example data from this question: glmmTMB with autocorrelation of irregular timesI have a dataset of 12 days of diary data. I am trying to use lme to model the effect of sleep quality on stress, with random intercept effects of participant and random slope effect of sleep quality. I am not particularly interested in asking whether there was change over time from diaryday 1 to 12, just in accounting for the time variable.
Oct 11, 2022 · The code below shows how the random effects (intercepts) of mixed models without autocorrelation terms can be extracted and plotted. However, this approach does not work when modelling autocorrelation in glmmTMB. Use reproducible example data from this question: glmmTMB with autocorrelation of irregular times . System_log
Mixed-effects models allow multiple levels of variability; AKA hierarchical models, multilevel models, multistratum models; Good references on mixed-effects models: Bolker [1–3] Gelman & Hill [4] Pinheiro & Bates [5].Jul 9, 2023 · For a linear mixed-effects model (LMM), as fit by lmer, this integral can be evaluated exactly. For a GLMM the integral must be approximated. For a GLMM the integral must be approximated. The most reliable approximation for GLMMs is adaptive Gauss-Hermite quadrature, at present implemented only for models with a single scalar random effect. Sep 16, 2018 · Recently I have made good use of Matlab's built-in functions for making linear mixed effects. Currently I am trying to model time-series data (neuronal activity) from cognitive experiments with the fitlme() function using two continuous fixed effects (linear speed and acceleration) and several, hierarchically nested categorical random factors (subject identity, experimental session and binned ... Therefore, even greater sampling rates will be required when autocorrelation is present to meet the levels prescribed by analyses of the power and precision when estimating individual variation using mixed effect models (e.g., Wolak et al. 2012; Dingemanse and Dochtermann 2013)An individual-tree diameter growth model was developed for Cunninghamia lanceolata in Fujian province, southeast China. Data were obtained from 72 plantation-grown China-fir trees in 24 single-species plots. Ordinary non-linear least squares regression was used to choose the best base model from among 5 theoretical growth equations; selection criteria were the smallest absolute mean residual ...I'm trying to model the evolution in time of one weed species (E. crus galli) within 4 different cropping systems (=treatment). I have 5 years of data spaced out equally in time and two repetitions (block) for each cropping system. Hence, block is a random factor. Measures were repeated each year on the same block (--> repeated measure mixed ...To do this, you would specify: m2 <- lmer (Obs ~ Day + Treatment + Day:Treatment + (Day | Subject), mydata) In this model: The intercept if the predicted score for the treatment reference category at Day=0. The coefficient for Day is the predicted change over time for each 1-unit increase in days for the treatment reference category. a combination of both models (ARMA). random effects that model independence among observations from the same site using GAMMs. That is, in addition to changing the basis as with the nottem example, we can also add complexity to the model by incorporating an autocorrelation structure or mixed effects using the gamm() function in the mgcv package Autocorrelation in linear mixed models (lme) Ask Question Asked 3 years, 1 month ago Modified 3 years, 1 month ago Viewed 4k times 4 To study the diving behaviour of whales, I have a dataframe where each row corresponds to a dive (id) carried out by a tagged individual (whale).a random effect for the autocorrelation. After introducing the extended mixed-effect location scale (E-MELS), ... mixed-effect models that have been, for example, combined with Lasso regression (e ... PROC MIXED in the SAS System provides a very flexible modeling environment for handling a variety of repeated measures problems. Random effects can be used to build hierarchical models correlating measurements made on the same level of a random factor, including subject-specific regression models, while a variety of covariance andc (Claudia Czado, TU Munich) – 11 – Likelihood Inference for LMM: 1) Estimation of β and γ for known G and R Estimation of β: Using (5), we have as MLE or weighted LSE of βAbstract. The use of linear mixed effects models (LMMs) is increasingly common in the analysis of biological data. Whilst LMMs offer a flexible approach to modelling a broad range of data types, ecological data are often complex and require complex model structures, and the fitting and interpretation of such models is not always straightforward.Linear mixed models allow for modeling fixed, random and repeated effects in analysis of variance models. “Factor effects are either fixed or random depending on how levels of factors that appear in the study are selected. An effect is called fixed if the levels in the study represent all possible levels of theSep 16, 2018 · Recently I have made good use of Matlab's built-in functions for making linear mixed effects. Currently I am trying to model time-series data (neuronal activity) from cognitive experiments with the fitlme() function using two continuous fixed effects (linear speed and acceleration) and several, hierarchically nested categorical random factors (subject identity, experimental session and binned ... 7. I want to specify different random effects in a model using nlme::lme (data at the bottom). The random effects are: 1) intercept and position varies over subject; 2) intercept varies over comparison. This is straightforward using lme4::lmer: lmer (rating ~ 1 + position + (1 + position | subject) + (1 | comparison), data=d) > ....